Team-based Learning in a Large Lecture Course: Effective

Team-based Learning in a Large Lecture Course: Effective

Team-based Learning in a Large Lecture Course:
Effective Even in Small Doses
Caron Inouye, Biological Science, California State University, East Bay, Hayward, CA
INTRODUCTION

100

A

80

Correct

60
40

Pre-activity

Post-activity

Figure 2. Proportion of students answering the assessment
question incorrectly (red) or correctly (blue) before and after
the team activity; N = 61.

Mean student score on the exam question that
assessed the team-discussed topic (x = 65.6%, SD =
19.2%, N = 73) were not significantly different
from mean overall exam score (x = 63.5%, SD =
28.9%, N = 73; paired t = -0.9, df = 72, p = 0.37).

B

Mean student score on isomorphic exam
questions assessing the team-discussed topic was
significantly greater in 2009 (x = 63.5%, SD =
28.9%, N = 73) than in 2008 (x = 37.6%, SD =
23.8%, N = 78) when no team activities occurred
(unpaired t = 6.1, df = 149, p << 0.001; Fig. 3). Mean Score on Question (%) 100 90 80 Figure 2. Screen shots of the pre-activity question (A), the questions given to the students to discuss during the team activity (B), and the isomorphic post-activity question (C). Student responses to questions A and C were recorded using iClicker. These questions were posed after a lecture unit on properties of animal cell membranes that enable homeoviscous adaptation. 2008 Year 2009 Figure 4. Comparison of overall mean exam scores (% of total points) for students taking the course in 2008 (when no team activities were done) and in 2009 (when team activities were performed). Students show marked improvements in both formative and summative assessments of concept learning once the concept has been actively discussed in a structured team discussion. Such peer discussion has also been shown to be an effective strategy in a very large (>300
student) lecture course.3
Students show some degree of content retention (> 3
weeks) once the content has been discussed in team
discussion.
A pair-wise comparison of individual student
performances on post-activity questions and overall
exam scores indicates that there is a consistency in
performance between the two assessments, so that
students who show concept understanding just after
team discussion also demonstrate this understanding in
another format some weeks later.
The lack of a statistically significant increase in exam
scores between 2008 and 2009 is a strong indicator of
the need to increase the frequency of these team-based
activities in the course.
These results suggest that even sporadic use of teambased learning (group discussion) activities is effective in
increasing understanding of particularly difficult
concepts, and more importantly, in the retention of
these concepts.

70
60
50
40
30
20

REFERENCES

10
0

C

90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0

CONCLUSIONS

20
0

METHODS
Course: Fall 2009 Principles of Animal
Physiology (BIOL 3151), a core requirement
for all biology majors, 80 students enrolled.
Pre-activity assessment: A specific lecture
unit (topic) was followed by a multiple-choice
question (Fig. 1A) with individual student
responses recorded via iClicker. The answer
was not discussed with students.
Team activity: Immediately after the preactivity, students divided into groups of 3-4 to
discuss (for 10-15 min.) a series of questions
for thought based on the topic (Fig. 1B).
Post-activity assessment: Individual student
responses to an isomorphic multiple-choice
question (Fig. 1C) were recorded via iClicker
and compared to pre-activity responses.
Assessment of content retention: A
formative exam was given 24 d after the team
activity. Student scores on a multi-part
question assessing the same topic as well as
overall exam performance were compared.
Comparison to previous year: Student
performances on isomorphic exam questions
of the same topic and overall exam
performance during the Fall 2008 offering of
BIOL 3151 when no team activities were done
were compared to the Fall 2009 scores.

Incorrect

Mean Exam Score (%)

There was a dramatic increase in the
percentage of students (from 44% to 74%)
correctly answering the isomorphic assessment
question immediately following the team activity
(Fig. 2).
% Student Responses

There are tomes of evidence that team-based
learning is highly effective in improving
comprehension, critical thinking, and content
retention when a course is delivered in a
student-centered, inquiry-based format.1,2
However, this format may necessitate a more
wholesale conversion of the lecture format
that is more feasible in a class with fewer
students. I addressed whether a more
conservative integration of team-based
activities had a significantly positive impact on
learning and retention in a moderately large
course in animal physiology.

RESULTS

2008

2009

Year
Figure 3. Difference in mean score (% of total points) on an
exam question assessing the particular topic between 2008
(when no team activity was done) and 2009 (with team
activity). The 2008 and 2009 exam questions were
isomorphic.

Mean overall student performances on exams
were not significantly different between 2008 (x
= 65.5%, SD = 15.7%, N = 49) and 2009 (x =
65.6%, SD = 19.2%, N = 73; unpaired t = 0.05, df
= 120, p = 0.48; Fig. 4).

1. Michael, J. 2006. Wheres the evidence that active learning works? Adv.
Physiol. Educ. 30: 159-167.
2. Prince, M. 2004. Does active learning work? A review of the research. J.
Engr. Educ. 93(3): 223-231.
3. Smith, M.K., W.B. Wood, W.K. Adams, C. Wieman, J.K. Knight, N. Guild, and
T.T. Su. 2009. Why peer discussion improves student performance on inclass concept questions. Science 323: 122-124.

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
I would like to thank the following for their help, encouragement, and support of this
project: ASM, NSF, and my Biology Scholars Program colleagues; Bernie Salvador
(IT); Michael Hedrick (Biology Chair); Michael Leung (Dean); and my infinitely
patient family (Ned, Dayton, & Mariko Garrett).
The CSU East Bay IRB has approved this project.

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • download.microsoft.com

    download.microsoft.com

    Quiz show template. To get started with the Quiz show template: Form five groups of students—one for each category. Assign categories to each group (or let them choose but ensure there are no repeats).
  • Desegregating Public Schools - SUNY Ulster

    Desegregating Public Schools - SUNY Ulster

    Times New Roman Arial Wingdings Soaring 1_Soaring The Struggle for Civil Rights The Great Migration World War II & the Cold War Desegregating the Schools The Reaction Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. and the Montgomery Bus Boycott The Southern Christian...
  • Measures of Central Tendency - FACULTY

    Measures of Central Tendency - FACULTY

    Median: The Median of X is the value of X such that an equal number are above and below X. Midpoint: Value of X that is half-way between the smallest and largest value. Mean: The Arithmetic Average (Sum of X,...
  • www.mcvts.net

    www.mcvts.net

    wear an ID badge. ID badge allows students to use the Lunch Point of Sale card system. First ID card is No Cost to parents. If card is lost, there is a $5.00 fee. Failure to wear/display ID card will...
  • The Essentials of Writing a Literary Essay

    The Essentials of Writing a Literary Essay

    Step 5 - Top Choice Themes Only. Narrow your focus by selecting only one or two universal themes to track. Consider choosing themes that you can relate to, that you're passionate about, and that can be supported with proofs throughout...
  • Investigation into Significant Anesthesia Adverse Events during the

    Investigation into Significant Anesthesia Adverse Events during the

    Despite the challenges in the POISE trial from 2008, there have been two subsequent studies in 2013 that endorse the assertion that metoprolol has a higher incidence of stroke as compared to Atenolol, Esmolol, Labetalol, and Bisoprolol. In animal models:...
  • ENGI 8926: Mechanical Design Project II

    ENGI 8926: Mechanical Design Project II

    *We are designing a downhole turbine assy because they allow the passage of fluid in the event of a stall and . Project Overview. Client: Advanced Drilling Group. Purpose: Design a downhole turbine-operated assembly to power a variety of downhole...
  • Title of talk

    Title of talk

    IAOS conference Shanghai October 2008 The role of national statistical societies Professor Denise Lievesley ISI and King's College London