Improving Argumentative Stance

Improving Argumentative Stance

Improving Argumentative Stance Prewriting and Organizational Strategy What is an argument? What is an academic argument? A means of discovering truth, negotiating differences, and solving problems An intellectual effort that is intended to solve a problem by drawing people together

Dos and do nots of academic argument Do look beyond surface and personal needs/ desires Do NOT communicate personal associations or reactions to a controversy Academic Argumentative Writing Definition: writing that attempts to prove the

validity of a point of view or an idea by presenting informed reasoned arguments. Informed reasoned argument: what you KNOW and what you THINK Academic argumentative writing engages others through language; it does not seek to win. Constructing an argument

What do I know? What are the key points your research brings out? What are the answers to the five Ws + how? Do any cultural or historical influences pertain? Which points are most important? Which are least? Why do I think this? What do I know that will help my reader understand my topic in a new way (vs. merely repeating source

material)? What dont I know that I need to include? Moving from knowing to thinking Summarize what you know from each source Evaluate what you read What in my source material makes we evaluate it the way I do? What is not in my source material that makes me

evaluate it the way I do? Is that clouding my reasoning? Moving from knowing to thinking Analyze the parts that make up your topic Break the whole into relative components How do they relate to one another? Allows you to see the topic differently and discover what you might say

Synthesize the ideas or parts Bring ideas together to make connections Consider whether disparate ideas actually do or can connect in some logical, reasonable way Choose a stance

Reflect on what your source materials brought together will support Choose a stance for which you have confidence in your defense Choose a stance you can argue sincerely Not taking a stance = Boring paper Argumentative Strategy/Structure Classical (Aristotle) Introduction: warms up the audience, establishes goodwill and rapport with the readers, and

communicates the thesis Narration: summarizes relevant background material, provides any information the audience needs to know about the environment and circumstances that produce the argument, and sets up the stakeswhats at risk in this question Classical Argument (Contd.) Proposition: presents the general argument you will be making and the lines the argument you will follow. Confirmation: presents and argues your points/claims in a logical order (usually strongest to

weakest or most obvious to most subtle) providing evidence for each claim (provides a chain of reasoning) Classical Argument (Contd.) Refutation and concession: looks at opposing viewpoints to the writers claims, anticipates objections from the audience, and allows as much of the opposing viewpoints as possible without weakening the thesis

Summation: provides a strong conclusion, amplifying the force of the argument, and showing the readers that this solution or viewpoint is the best for meeting the circumstances Reminds the reader whats at stake and the importance of the situation Provides sense of closure vs. breaking off Variations on Classical Argument: Logical Order Climactic order

Introduce controversy ending with a thesis Build from least powerful to most powerful argument Rank sub-points in order from least to most powerful also Based on the principle of primacy/recency Two sides of the controversy Introduce controversy ending with thesis

Present opposing view Present your point of view Show and connect evidence to support why your view is better Present and respond to counter arguments Introduce controversy ending with a thesis Present main counter argument Show its flaws

Present your argument Show its strengths A variation of the above is to concede the merits of the counter argument then show the greater merits of your argument Concession (Rogerian Argument) Introduction that leads to thesis Summarize opposing points acknowledging

their merit Transition paragraph that winds down to your position (On the other hand. . . ); never say the other side is wrong or that yours is better Support your position Conclude Other logical strategies Problem/solution

Introduce Define problem Give some background Provide solution Compare and contrast Consider similarities and differences among various sources Two organizational patterns Compare and Contrast

By source or subject Introduce controversy Summarize each source or subject Discuss both the obvious and the more subtle similarities or differences Compare and contrast main features of each Be sure that all discussion supports the thesis Works best if summaries can be brief

Compare and Contrast By criteria (more complex) Introduce controversy Compare or contrast several authors simultaneously Examine their views and discuss the comparisons or the contrasts at the same time

Works best if multiple points are being discussed or if passages are long and complex

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • Biomechanics


    A shot putter performs turns to increase impulse by maximising the time over which a force is applied. Starter Activity. Complete True and False activity to demonstrate knowledge gained last week and to introduce forces. ... Biomechanics Last modified by:
  • 2014 Loss of Load Probability Assessment for NERC

    2014 Loss of Load Probability Assessment for NERC

    Then, the interface limits between the bubbles modeled in the 2014 LOLP study were estimated by subtracting the MW amount of the STP units from the AC transfer limit since the LOLP study assumed the STP units inside the Houston...
  • Best Evidence - Nell Hodgson Woodruff School of Nursing

    Best Evidence - Nell Hodgson Woodruff School of Nursing

    Best Learning is Active learning. Self directed learning is active and changes practice. Every patient can tell a story. Review each patient's problem list and do active 2 min look-ups to refresh your brain and practice

    ResistingPressureon. ComponentsandCladding. S. h. e. a. th. gable. end. walls. with. wo. o. d. s. t. ruc. t. ural. panel. s, such. as. pl. y. wood. or. oriented. st ...
  • Feudal Powers in Japan

    Feudal Powers in Japan

    Developed over a thousand years but came to be called Shinto (Shintoism) Shinto means "way of the gods." Very Nature orientated - believed that divine spirits dwell in nature. These spirits are called Kami. Kami were said to dwell in...
  • Understanding poverty | @NicSpaull Guest lecture: Theology

    Understanding poverty | @NicSpaull Guest lecture: Theology

    if one child of school-going age does not go to school. Water. deprivation is defined as not having piped water on site. Deprivation in . child mortality . is indicated by a child having died before age 15. Nutritional. deprivation...
  • Zdeslav Hrepic Dissertation Defense Kansas State University Physics

    Zdeslav Hrepic Dissertation Defense Kansas State University Physics

    How reliable is the test? How valid is the test? Starting point in test creation: Identifying mental models of sound propagation Hrepic, Z., Zollman, D., & Rebello, S. (2002). Identifying students' models of sound propagation. Paper presented at the 2002...
  • Introduction - University of Tennessee at Chattanooga

    Introduction - University of Tennessee at Chattanooga

    OS Concepts. An operating system (OS) provides the interface between the users of a computer and that computer's hardware.. An operating system manages the ways applications access the resources in a computer, including its disk drives, CPU, main memory, input...